| Oct 10, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 9 MINT #132013350 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $104.95 |
| Oct 10, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 9 MINT #119298793 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $104.95 |
| Oct 10, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon 2017 XY Black Star Promos Magearna XY186 Full Art Holo PSA 10 · eBay | Auction | $6,000.00 |
| Oct 9, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 9 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $159.00 |
| Oct 9, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 9 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $125.00 |
| Oct 8, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 9 MINT #119298810 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $104.95 |
| Oct 7, 26 | PSA 10 | PSA 10 Pokemon TCG 2017 XY Black Star Promo Magearna XY186 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $4,500.00 |
| Oct 7, 26 | TAG 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo TAG 10 Pop 1 At The Time Of Listing · eBay | Auction | $135.00 |
| Oct 6, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 Pokemon XY Promo Mage Myth Alt Art Magearna #XY186 PSA 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $3,499.00 |
| Oct 6, 26 | PSA 8 | Pokemon 2017 Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 8 · eBay | Auction | $37.99 |
| Oct 6, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 9 MINT #132013348 · eBay | Auction | $104.95 |
| Oct 5, 26 | PSA 9 | Magearna Holo Black Star Promo PSA 9 MINT 2017 Pokemon XY Mythical #XY186 · eBay | Auction | $149.99 |
| Oct 4, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 Mythical Coll. Full Art PSA 10 Gem Mint · eBay | Auction | $3,750.00 |
| Oct 4, 26 | PSA 9 | Pokémon Magearna XY186 Black Star Promo PSA 9 Mint · eBay | Auction | $91.50 |
| Oct 4, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon Magearna XY186 Full Art Mythical Collection Black Star Promo PSA 10 Gem · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $3,999.99 |
| Oct 2, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $112.50 |
| Oct 1, 26 | CGC 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Mythical Collection Promo 2017 CGC 10 GEM MINT LOW POP · eBay | Auction | $450.00 |
| Sep 30, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 Pokemon XY Promo Mage Myth Alt Art Magearna #XY186 PSA 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $1,999.00 |
| Sep 30, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 PM XY Black Star FA/Magearna Holo Promo Mage.Myth.Coll #XY186 PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $90.00 |
| Sep 30, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 10 BRAND NEW CERT · eBay | Auction | $4,000.00 |
| Sep 25, 26 | BGS 9.5 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo BGS 9.5 · eBay | Auction | $400.00 |
| Sep 23, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon TCG 2017 Magearna XY186 XY Black Star Promo Full Art Holo PSA 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $2,600.00 |
| Sep 22, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon TCG Magearna XY186 PSA 10 2017 English Holo Full Art XY Black Star · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $2,800.00 |
| Sep 21, 26 | CGC 8.5 | 2017 Pokemon XY Black Star Promo Mythical Collection Full Art Magearna #XY186 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+ · Fanatics | Auction | $24.00 |
| Sep 21, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,999.00 |
| Sep 21, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 Pokemon Magearna Holo Full Art XY Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 10 Gem Mint 💎 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,999.99 |
| Sep 20, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 Pokemon Magearna Holo Full Art XY Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 10 Gem Mint · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,358.40 |
| Sep 20, 26 | PSA 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo Promo Black Star PSA 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $2,000.00 |
| Sep 17, 26 | PSA 9 | Pokemon 2017 Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $95.00 |
| Sep 17, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon TCG Magearna XY186 Holo Promo Card Promo Cards Set PSA 10 English 2017 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,550.00 |
| Sep 17, 26 | PSA 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo Black Star Promo PSA 10 · eBay | Auction | $1,499.00 |
| Sep 13, 26 | PSA 9 | Pokemon Company Magearna XY186 XY Promo Holo EN 2017 Pokemon TCG PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $70.00 |
| Sep 7, 26 | CGC 9 | 2017 Pokemon XY Black Star Promo Mythical Collection Full Art Magearna #XY186 CGC 9 MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $31.20 |
| Aug 31, 26 | PSA 9 | Pokemon Company Magearna XY186 XY Promo Holo EN 2017 Pokemon TCG PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $68.00 |
| Aug 29, 26 | PSA 9 | The Pokémon Company Magearna XY Promo Holo XY186 2017 PSA 9 90HP · eBay | Auction | $80.00 |
| Aug 23, 26 | PSA 9 | PSA 9 MINT - Magearna #XY186 XY Magearna Mythical Collection HOLO Promo Full Art · eBay | Auction | $68.00 |
| Aug 22, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 10 GEM MINT #115718625 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,499.95 |
| Aug 20, 26 | PSA 9 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo PSA 9 NEW CERT!! · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $100.00 |
| Aug 18, 26 | PSA 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Promo Holo 2017 PSA 10 · eBay | Auction | $1,500.00 |
| Aug 18, 26 | PSA 10 | Magearna XY186 XY Promos PSA 10 Pokemon Card Holo · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,106.99 |
| Aug 18, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon Magearna XY186 XY Holo Promo PSA 10 *Low Pop* · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $1,299.99 |
| Aug 17, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 Pokemon XY Black Star Promo Mythical Collection Full Art Magearna #XY186 PSA 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $930.00 |
| Aug 4, 26 | PSA 8 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 8 NM #119298785 · eBay | Auction | $54.95 |
| Aug 3, 26 | PSA 9 | Pokemon 2017 Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $99.99 |
| Aug 2, 26 | PSA 9 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $80.94 |
| Jul 27, 26 | PSA 7 | Magearna XY186 XY Holo PSA 7 NEW CERT!! · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $25.00 |
| Jul 26, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO MAGEARNA #XY186 HOLO PSA 10 GEM MINT #133381637 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $900.00 |
| Jul 26, 26 | PSA 10 | 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $850.00 |
| Jul 26, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokemon Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 Mythical Coll. Full Art PSA 10 Gem Mint · eBay | Auction | $950.00 |
| Jul 26, 26 | Ungraded | 2017 Pokemon TCG Magearna XY186 NM Full Art Holo Black Star Promo XY Promo · eBay | Auction | $34.00 |
