| Oct 6, 26 | CGC 10 | The Pokemon Company Ponyta 004/034 (2023) Trading Card Game Classic Holo CGC 10 · eBay | Auction | $36.00 |
| Oct 5, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $12.00 |
| Oct 5, 26 | PSA 8 | POKEMON CLC-TRADING CARD GAME CLASSIC CHARIZARD & HO-OH EX DECK PONYTA PSA 8 · eBay | Auction | $14.99 |
| Sep 30, 26 | cgc9_6 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 9.5 MINT+ · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $12.00 |
| Sep 28, 26 | CGC 10 | Ponyta 004/034 Charizard & Ho-Oh EX Deck Holo Pokemon CGC 10 Gem Mint · eBay | Auction | $10.33 |
| Sep 15, 26 | PSA 10 | PSA 10 Ponyta CLC 004 TCG Classic Collection Holo Pokemon Card 2023 · eBay | Auction | $67.00 |
| Sep 9, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Trading Card Game Classic #004/032 Ponyta CGC 10 Pristine · eBay | Auction | $31.95 |
| Sep 1, 26 | CGC 10 | CGC Pristine 10 - 2023 Pokemon Charizard & Ho-Oh ex Deck Ponyta #004 · eBay | Auction | $22.99 |
| Sep 1, 26 | Ungraded | GEM MINT 10 Holo Ponyta 004/034 Pokemon Classic Collection English · eBay | Auction | $10.00 |
| Sep 1, 26 | CGC 9 | Ponyta 004/034 Trading Card Game Classic Holo CGC 9 Slab · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $7.99 |
| Sep 1, 26 | CGC 10 | Ponyta Pokémon 2023 TCG Classic 004/034 Holo CGC PRISTINE 10 · eBay | Auction | $34.99 |
| Aug 31, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $12.00 |
| Aug 31, 26 | CGC 9 | Pokemon TCG Classic Ponyta 004/034 CGC 9 Mint · eBay | Auction | $11.50 |
| Aug 27, 26 | CGC 9 | Ponyta 004/034 Charizard & Ho-Oh EX Deck Holo Pokemon CGC 9 Mint · eBay | Auction | $1.99 |
| Aug 26, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $15.00 |
| Aug 25, 26 | CGC 10 | Pokemon Ponyta Holo 004/034 from Classic Collection in a CGC Pristine 10 !! · eBay | Auction | $34.00 |
| Aug 24, 26 | PSA 10 | POKEMON CLC-TRADING CARD GAME CLASSIC CHARIZARD & HO-OH EX DECK PONYTA PSA 10 · eBay | Auction | $59.99 |
| Aug 23, 26 | CGC 10 | Pokemon 2023 Ponyta 004/034 Holo Trading Card Game Classic GEM MINT CGC 10 · eBay | Auction | $8.50 |
| Aug 23, 26 | CGC 10 | Pokemon 2023 Ponyta 004/034 Holo Trading Card Game Classic GEM MINT CGC 10 · eBay | Auction | $15.50 |
| Aug 15, 26 | PSA 10 | Pokémon TCG Ponyta Trading Card 004/034 Classic Holo AGS 9.5 (PSA 10 Potential) · eBay | Auction | $20.00 |
| Aug 14, 26 | CGC 9 | CGC 9 Ponyta Trading Card Game Classic 004/034 Holo Classic Collection ENG · eBay | Auction | $9.99 |
| Aug 14, 26 | CGC 10 | Ponyta 004/034 Classic Holo - CGC Gem Mint 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $20.00 |
| Aug 5, 26 | CGC 10 | CGC Gem Mint 10 Ponyta Holo #004 Classic Collection Pokemon 2023 Charizard Deck · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $11.90 |
| Jul 29, 26 | CGC 9 | PONYTA 2023 POKEMON TCG CLASSIC CHARIZARD HO-OH EX DECK HOLO 004/034 CGC 9 Q5986 · eBay | Auction | $12.00 |
| Jul 11, 26 | PSA 9 | 2023 POKEMON CLC CLASSIC CHARIZARD & HO-OH ex DECK #004 PONYTA PSA 9 · eBay | Auction | $9.99 |
| Jun 26, 26 | CGC 8.5 | 2023 Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+ · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $10.00 |
| Jun 26, 26 | CGC 9 | Pokemon TCG CGC 9 Ponyta 004/034 Holo · eBay | Auction | $6.99 |
| Jun 24, 26 | CGC 9.5 | Pokemon Ponyta 004/034 Trading Card Game Classic 2023 EN Holo CGC 9.5 · eBay | Auction | $6.50 |
| Jun 7, 26 | CGC 8.5 | Pokemon TCG CGC 8.5 Ponyta 004/034 Holo · eBay | Auction | $2.75 |
| Jun 1, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Trading Card Game Classic #004/034 Ponyta CGC 10 · eBay | Auction | $13.50 |
| May 31, 26 | Ungraded | Pokémon Ponyta Holo Classic Collection 004/034 TCG Classic 60HP AGS 9.5 · eBay | Auction | $2.00 |
| May 29, 26 | CGC 10 | CGC 10 Ponyta 004/032 Charizard & Ho-Oh ex Deck Trading Card Game Classic CLL · eBay | Auction | $10.80 |
| May 25, 26 | CGC 10 | CGC Gem Mint 10 Ponyta 004/034 TCG Classic Collection Holo Pokemon · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $14.10 |
| May 24, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 POKEMON TRADING CARD GAME CLASSIC #004/034 PONYTA CGC 10 GEM MINT · eBay | Auction | $20.00 |
| May 19, 26 | Ungraded | Ponyta Original Top Pop Classic Deck 004/034 Certified Pristine 10 Pokémon · eBay | Auction | $24.50 |
| May 19, 26 | CGC 10 | Pokémon Ponyta 004/034 Trading Card Game Classic Holo CGC 10 2023 60 HP · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $6.99 |
| May 18, 26 | CGC 9.5 | 2023 Pokemon SV TCG Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 9.5 MINT+ · Fanatics | Auction | $8.40 |
| Apr 27, 26 | CGC 8.5 | 2023 Pokemon SV TCG Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+ · Fanatics | Auction | $7.20 |
| Apr 27, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $9.60 |
| Apr 27, 26 | CGC 9.5 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 9.5 MINT+ · Fanatics | Auction | $7.20 |
| Apr 24, 26 | CGC 10 | Pokémon Ponyta 004/034 Trading Card Game Classic Collection Holo CGC 10 Gem Mint · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $15.99 |
| Apr 20, 26 | CGC 10 | The Pokémon Company Ponyta Trading Card Game Classic 004/034 2023 Holo CGC 10 · eBay | Buy It Now · Best offer | $19.99 |
| Apr 16, 26 | CGC 9.5 | Pokemon CGC 9.5 Ponyta Trading Card Game Classic 004/034 2023 Holo · eBay | Auction | $8.50 |
| Apr 10, 26 | CGC 9.5 | Pokémon Ponyta CGC 9.5 Mint Trading Card Game Classic Holo 004/034 2023 · eBay | Auction | $9.99 |
| Mar 31, 26 | Ungraded | Ponyta Pokemon 2023 Trading Card Game Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck · eBay | Auction | $13.99 |
| Mar 9, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $14.40 |
| Mar 5, 26 | CGC 9 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Charizard & Ho-Oh Ex Deck Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 9 MINT · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $24.00 |
| Mar 2, 26 | PSA 9 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 PSA 9 MINT · Fanatics | Auction | $12.00 |
| Feb 23, 26 | Ungraded | Ponyta 004/034 Trading Card Game Classic Holo · eBay | Auction | $24.99 |
| Feb 20, 26 | CGC 10 | 2023 Pokemon TCG Classic Collection Holo Ponyta #4 CGC 10 GEM MINT · Fanatics | Buy It Now | $15.00 |
